Skip to content 
Taxation is a fundamental aspect of any country’s economy, and taxpayers play a significant role. Every taxpayer must file their tax returns accurately and on time. However, only some know the difference between careless and deliberate actions regarding mistakes and misrepresenting financials to HMRC. This lack of understanding can lead to severe consequences, including penalties and legal action.
According to a report by HMRC, over 600,000 taxpayers missed the deadline for filing their tax returns in 2020. Taxpayers need to be aware of the consequences of their actions and the potential penalties they could face if they fail to comply with HMRC guidelines.
Definitions of Careless and Deliberate
Understanding the difference between careless and deliberate actions is crucial because it can affect the severity of the penalties imposed by HMRC.
Careless Action
A careless action, as defined by HMRC, is one where a person or business makes a mistake due to a lack of reasonable care. This can include errors such as forgetting to include income on a tax return, failing to keep accurate records, or making simple miscalculations. It is important to note that careless actions are not intentional but result from negligence or oversight. For example, if a person fails to report all their income on their tax return because he thought he had made a loss or already included income, they may be subject to a penalty of up to 30% and interest on the tax payable.
Deliberate Action
On the other hand, a deliberate action is one where a person or business knowingly and intentionally takes steps to evade tax or mislead HMRC. This can include underreporting income, claiming false expenses, or failing to register for VAT. Deliberate actions are considered more serious than careless actions and can result in much harsher penalties. A deliberate action can result in significant fines and even criminal prosecution. For example, if a person deliberately underreports their income on their tax return, they may be penalised up to 300% of the tax owed and possible criminal charges. For example, a business owner deliberately fails to register for VAT to avoid paying the tax. They continue to operate without registering for several years, knowingly evading their tax obligations. This is considered deliberate as it was done intentionally to avoid paying taxes.
Differences in Intentions
The intention behind an action plays a crucial role in determining our actions’ moral and ethical implications. Whether an action is deliberate or careless can significantly impact how it is perceived and judged.
- Careless actions are often the result of thoughtlessness, inattention, or negligence. They are actions that are not intended to cause harm but may have unintended consequences. It is important to note that careless actions can also result from distractions.
- Deliberate actions are carried out with a specific intention or purpose in mind. These actions are often premeditated and are intended to achieve a particular outcome. However, deliberate actions can also result in unintended consequences.
Impact of Intentions on Consequences
The intention behind an action can also impact the severity of the consequences. For example, if someone accidentally breaks a vase, the consequences may be less severe than if someone deliberately smashes it in anger. In the first case, the action was careless, and the intention was not to cause harm. In the second case, the action was deliberate, and the intention was to cause harm.
Avoiding careless actions with tax compliance helps comply with rules, reduce tax liability, and save time and money in the long term. On the other hand, not submitting accurate tax returns and financials can lead to severe outcomes, like heavy fines and legal action, underscoring the necessity of accurate, current information. To avoid risks of non-compliance and penalties, it’s important to maintain accurate records and seek professional advice when necessary, as per the regulations set by HMRC. If you need help with Tax Investigations ; we have tax experts who can help you. Call our office to discuss your case.