Skip to content 
The UK’s Human Rights Act 1998 enshrines pivotal civil liberties that protect individuals when interfacing with the state, including during HMRC tax investigations. This article examines how the Act’s principles uphold taxpayer rights and ensure fair treatment during HMRC inquiries.
The Human Rights Act came into force in 2000, incorporating the fundamental rights outlined in the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law. It mandates that public bodies like HMRC abide by these rights.
Key provisions include Article 6, outlining the right to a fair trial, and Article 8, establishing the right to respect for private life and correspondence. Article 1 of the First Protocol also protects the peaceful enjoyment of possessions. When conducting tax investigations, HMRC must adhere to these rights. This means:
- Taxpayers have the right to a fair process where they can fully present their case and challenge HMRC’s evidence. The procedures must be transparent, balanced and fair.
- The presumption of innocence dictates that the taxpayer is innocent until HMRC proves liability beyond a reasonable doubt. The burden of proof is on HMRC.
- Complex cases may warrant legal aid to ensure taxpayers can adequately defend themselves. Factors like potential serious outcomes and case complexity determine if aid is granted.
- HMRC’s powers have limits. Any information requested must be relevant and not unduly intrusive. Speculative ‘fishing expeditions’ violate privacy rights.
- HMRC must balance collecting taxes versus excessively burdening taxpayers. Actions cannot violate the right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions.
Additional taxpayer rights under the Act include appealing penalties if reasonable excuses exist, receiving interpreting services when needed, and getting extra time or payment plans if suitable. The Human Rights Act upholds essential taxpayer rights and protections against potential overreach during HMRC probes. The principles of fair trials, presumption of innocence, proportionality and privacy all aim to ensure justice prevails, cementing the Act as a bulwark against abuse of state power. Understanding these rights is key for taxpayers facing scrutiny.
For Tax Investigations, tax resolution or compliance, please contact Tax Accountant at 0800 135 7323 or email info@taxaccountant.co.uk for expert advice.