Skip to content 
As a landlord, understanding the difference between repairs and improvements can save you money on taxes. Repairs, like fixing a leaky roof or repainting, are deductible in the year they occur. Improvements, such as adding a new room or upgrading a kitchen, enhance property value and must be depreciated over time. Knowing this distinction is vital for your profits and financial health as a landlord.
What Are Repairs?
Repairs are all about fixing something that’s broken or worn out. Think of them as the small, necessary fixes that keep your property in good working order. Here’s how to think about repairs:
- Purpose: The main goal is to restore something to its original condition. If a door is squeaky or a window is cracked, repairing it gets it back to how it was before the problem started.
- Examples: Fixing a broken window or door lock
- Repairing damaged roof tiles or gutters
- Repainting walls that have scuffed or chipped
- Replacing a broken appliance like a dishwasher or stove
- Mending faulty wiring or plumbing that isn’t working properly
Because these repairs are done to bring the property back to its usual state and ensure everything runs smoothly, the costs are usually seen as a regular expense. This means they are often fully tax-deductible. In simple words, if you spend money on repairs, you can subtract that expense from your rental income, reducing the amount of tax you owe for the year.
For instance, if your tenant complains about a broken boiler and you call a plumber to fix it, the money you pay for that repair can typically be deducted from your income. If you’re using a tax method called the “simplified cash basis” (for properties earning less than a certain amount), this deduction can help lower your taxable profit right away.
What Are Improvements?
Improvements, on the other hand, go a step further. Instead of just fixing something, improvements actually enhance or expand the property. They add new value, functionality, or comfort to the space. Here’s a clearer picture:
- Purpose: The goal of an improvement is not just to fix but to upgrade. This could mean adding a new feature or making an area better than it was originally.
- Examples: Adding an extra room or extension to the property
- Converting a loft into a usable bedroom
- Upgrading the kitchen with modern appliances and cabinets
- Installing a new bathroom or extra bathrooms
- Making an area that was once unusable into a livable space
Unlike repairs, improvements are usually considered capital spending. What does that mean for you? Instead of getting a tax break immediately, the cost of improvements is spread out over time. This is done through something called capital allowances or by adjusting the base cost when you eventually sell the property. For example, if you spend a large sum to add a new bedroom with an ensuite bathroom, you won’t get an immediate tax deduction. However, when you sell the property, that money will help reduce the gain on which you have to pay tax.
When Repairs and Improvements Overlap
Sometimes, it isn’t so clear whether a job is a repair or an improvement. Let’s look at a few examples to see how these situations can be tricky:
- Replacing a Damaged Roof: If only a few roof tiles are blown off in a storm and you replace them with tiles similar to the originals, this is likely a repair. The main goal here is to fix the damage, and you’re not really changing anything about the property. However, if you decide to replace the entire roof with a new, modern design that lasts longer, then a portion of that cost might be considered an improvement. In this case, only the part that is strictly repairing the damage is immediately deductible, while the extra cost of upgrading the roof is treated as capital expenditure.
- Upgrading Windows: Suppose your property has old single-glazed windows that are not very energy-efficient, and you replace them with double-glazed windows. If the new windows are not significantly different from the originals—only better quality—the expense might still be counted as a repair. However, if the new windows add substantial energy efficiency and extra functionality, then part of the cost might be seen as an improvement. The tax treatment can vary depending on the specifics.
- Bathroom Refurbishment: Imagine you’re updating a dated bathroom. Just fixing the old fixtures, like re-caulking or replacing a broken tap, is a repair. However, if you replace the entire bathroom, install a high-end suite, install modern tiling, and even install underfloor heating, the whole project might be categorized as an improvement. In this situation, you’re enhancing the property’s value and the quality of life for the tenants, so the cost is treated as capital spending.
Why Does the Distinction Matter?
Understanding whether an expense is a repair or an improvement isn’t just a matter of bookkeeping—it can significantly affect your tax bill. Here’s why:
- Immediate Tax Deductions vs. Long-Term Benefits: When you classify an expense as a repair, you get an immediate tax deduction. This means you can reduce your taxable income right away. On the other hand, improvements are spread out over time. This delay means you don’t get an immediate tax break, although you may benefit when you eventually sell the property.
- Budgeting and Cash Flow: Knowing the difference helps you plan your spending. If you know that repair costs will give you an immediate tax benefit, you might be more inclined to tackle urgent fixes sooner rather than later. Improvements, while important for adding value, require more careful long-term budgeting.
- Avoiding Surprises at Tax Time: Incorrectly categorizing an expense can lead to unexpected tax bills. If you accidentally treat an improvement as a repair, you might later find that you owe more in taxes. Being clear on what falls into each category helps ensure you’re taking full advantage of the right tax relief options.
How to Tell the Difference
Here are some key points to consider when trying to decide if a job is a repair or an improvement:
- Degree of Enhancement: Ask yourself if the work restores something to its original state or actually improves the property. A basic fix is a repair; a change that boosts performance or adds new features is an improvement.
- Scope of the Work: Consider whether you’re fixing one small part of the property or overhauling an entire system or room. Small fixes are generally repairs, but big projects that change the look or functionality are usually improvements.
- Old vs. New: Look at what you’re using to fix or upgrade the property. If you’re using materials that are almost the same as the originals, it’s likely a repair. If the materials are completely new and offer extra benefits (like energy efficiency or added luxury), then it might be an improvement.
- Incidental vs. Substantial Upgrades: Sometimes, even if you’re making a change that seems like an upgrade, if it’s done as part of a necessary repair, the tax authorities might still let you claim it as a repair. For example, if you replace parts of a roof that was damaged, and the new parts are only slightly better, you might still be able to count it as a repair.
Expert Advice: When in Doubt, Ask a Specialist
Because the line between repairs and improvements can sometimes be blurry, it’s always a good idea to consult with a property tax specialist if you’re unsure. They can review your specific situation and help you decide how to categorize the expense correctly. Getting our expert tax advice early on can save you from potential tax headaches lat