Skip to content 
The complexities surrounding VAT refunds for holding companies in the UK have long been challenging in their operations. Traditionally, holding companies, entities that own shares in other companies, have found it difficult to recover VAT due to the nature of their activities and the stringent regulations set by HMRC (Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs). This article delves into the nuanced landscape of VAT refunds for holding companies, providing insights into the evolving perspective of the HMRC and the implications for these entities.
Historically, holding companies have been seen primarily as passive entities, their main activities being holding and selling shares in subsidiaries and collecting dividends. These activities, however, do not qualify as ‘business activities’ for VAT purposes. Hence, they have not been permitted to register for VAT or recover any VAT incurred on their supplier costs. This has posed significant challenges, especially when these companies undertake substantial financial operations such as structuring a takeover or deciding to list on a stock exchange, where the VAT component of costs can be substantial.
However, it’s important to note that not all holding companies fit into this traditional framework. Many holding companies extend their operations beyond merely holding investments, playing an active role in day-to-day management or providing interest-bearing commercial loans to their overseas subsidiaries. These activities can be recognised as business activities for VAT purposes. In such instances, the onus is on the holding company to validate its position as a business using documentary evidence. This requirement has led to numerous legal disputes, with holding companies facing challenges in reclaiming their VAT costs due to issues with the preservation of necessary evidence or discrepancies between the evidence and the presented facts.
Regular suppliers and chargers of goods or services are generally eligible for VAT registration. There are two categories of VAT registration: mandatory (triggered when the business exceeds registration thresholds) and voluntary (applicable when such thresholds are not exceeded, but the company is still in business). Voluntary VAT registration applications receive more rigorous scrutiny from HMRC, particularly for businesses that plan to start trading soon but need more evidence of historical trading. For holding companies, the scrutiny level is even higher due to the nature of their operations.
For holding companies seeking voluntary VAT registration, HMRC requires evidence supporting their intent to operate as a business. This could include documented management or loan agreements of a commercial nature or invoices issued to subsidiaries in a businesslike manner. If the holding company hasn’t yet entered into agreements, HMRC will seek other evidence, such as signed board minutes, indicating an intention to provide such services when costs were incurred and at the effective date of VAT registration.
In recent times, HMRC’s approach has seen some slight changes. While it used to require satisfactory documentary evidence before approving a holding company’s VAT registration, there have been instances where HMRC approves the VAT registration application but immediately audits the first VAT return, which often involves a substantial VAT refund. This indicates a slight shift in HMRC’s stance, albeit with the same emphasis on ensuring the legitimacy of business activities.
Each holding company’s case is unique and requires a balanced approach based on specific facts and available evidence. It’s crucial that holding companies ensure their agreements and evidence are properly reviewed by a VAT expert to reflect commercial reality and meet the relevant criteria. With the correct approach and documentation, it is possible for holding companies to navigate the complexities of VAT registration and recovery successfully. Recent VAT cases such as Bluejay Mining PLC and Tower Resources PLC, which ruled in favour of the taxpayer, provide some degree of certainty for holding companies seeking to recover input tax incurred.
In conclusion, the landscape for VAT refunds for holding companies in the UK is gradually changing. While the regulations are still stringent, holding companies engaging in business operations may qualify for VAT refunds. However, they must properly document their activities, meet HMRC’s strict evidence requirements, and seek expert advice to navigate the complex VAT laws successfully. By doing so, they can recover substantial costs, significantly enhancing their financial performance and contributing to their overall business success.